Expressionism Is a Stance Most Concerned With the Idea That Great Art Must

Open Preview

See a Problem?

We'd love your help. Let the states know what'southward wrong with this preview of Art equally Fine art by Advert Reinhardt.

Thanks for telling u.s. about the problem.

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions most Art as Art, please sign upwards.

Exist the starting time to ask a question nigh Art as Fine art

Community Reviews

· 49 ratings · 12 reviews

Start your review of Art as Fine art: The Selected Writings

Feb 16, 2017 Michael rated it really liked information technology

120119: and why this is non v? considering, finally, sadly, i have not experienced his bodily fine art. only i just looked at work by japanese contemporary creative person takahi murakami, and in images it becomes clearer that reinhardt is outside whatever 1 culture, politics, critiques, because information technology is exactly not the usual repertoire of artistic techniques that he employs. non gestures, symbols, allusion, culture, history. art every bit art. damn, i want to run into his piece of work...

first review: this is 4 because i like his wor

120119: and why this is not v? because, finally, sadly, i take non experienced his bodily art. but i only looked at work by japanese contemporary artist takahi murakami, and in images it becomes clearer that reinhardt is exterior any one culture, politics, critiques, considering it is exactly not the usual repertoire of artistic techniques that he employs. not gestures, symbols, innuendo, culture, history. art as art. damn, i want to see his work...

first review: this is four because i like his work, his intention, his philosophical, his pure artistic aspiration. 'art as art' could be confused with 'for arts sake', but his point is more strict: art is not for any purpose. fine art is art. as such, reinhardt is an abstract artist concerned with art, non interested in illustrating, depicting, summoning, either the usual 'real world' or the world as interpreted in non-art ways, expressionism, surrealism, primitivism... etc. and then i adore his attitude, his ideas, his historical sensation, his insistence and moral stance...

my experience of his piece of work is entirely past reproductions, which are always less than. his work may crave some art pedagogy- i go on in all arts the prejudice that whatever it is, information technology must be effective, must piece of work, and everything else is ancillary. art is art. he never claims to be a poet, though his notes often enough seem kind of beat. this might exist perfect instance of fine art having to exist in exactly the right medium for it to work. poesy is not for reinhardt. essays, interviews, monologues, are much better. and the art itself is best...

...more

Jun xxx, 2015 Peter Landau rated information technology really liked it

When I recently visited the Whitney Museum of American Fine art, I went with my oldest son and a friend, who is a cracking cartoonist. The countdown exhibition for the newly built Whitney is a survey of American art cast over the final century, curated from the museum'due south permanent collection. My cartoonist friend figured he'd like everything until we got to the mid-century, as he'southward a champion of figurative fine art and dismissive of the turn towards concept over arts and crafts and technique. His hate bout was thoroughl When I recently visited the Whitney Museum of American Art, I went with my oldest son and a friend, who is a neat cartoonist. The inaugural exhibition for the newly built Whitney is a survey of American art cast over the last century, curated from the museum'south permanent collection. My cartoonist friend figured he'd like everything until we got to the mid-century, every bit he'due south a champion of figurative art and dismissive of the turn towards concept over craft and technique. His hate tour was thoroughly entertaining, fifty-fifty if I didn't concord with much of it. I felt the same way reading Fine art Equally Art: THE SELECTED WRITINGS past Ad Reinhardt. Reinhardt, also a cartoonist only ane of the near severe of abstract artists, has strong opinions of what makes art, ideals in fine art, what is art education, even faith and art. His is a pure class, platonic, that is uncorrupted by isms or, for that thing, annihilation. As the title suggests, this is art for fine art alone, non fine art as this, that or annihilation else. Reinhardt may seek a rarified space for art, simply he does information technology with style and a wicked humor. And he's a pretty good cartoonist, likewise. For the terminal seven years of his life all he did was pigment five-foot-by-5-foot canvases of black paintings. I wish there was one of his black paintings at the Whitney. I actually wanted the experience of existence in their presence. It would have articulated what his writings cannot and never were intended to say. ...more

January 30, 2012 Andrew Businesswoman rated information technology it was amazing

To review this would be to have a position towards it. I write no review in light of it. Information technology is a book with or without my review. It is because it is. Ad would have been completely indifferent to all of this. lol

I reviewed Ad Reinhardt's satirical cartoons in an fine art history grade a long time ago. I am also open to the thought of the black painting as an "end" to painting (I doubtfulness one in x people surveyed could proper noun an artist or work created after 1970; I doubtfulness i in 50 could name 1 fabricated later on 1980). Art as Art has been on my "to read" shelf for years.

I was a little disappointed by how irascible Reinhardt was. Possibly de Kooning and Rothko* need to be depicted as the petit bourgeois accessories to

I reviewed Ad Reinhardt's satirical cartoons in an art history class a long time ago. I am also open to the thought of the black painting as an "stop" to painting (I doubt one in ten people surveyed could name an creative person or piece of work created after 1970; I doubt one in fifty could name ane made afterward 1980). Art as Art has been on my "to read" shelf for years.

I was a piffling disappointed by how irascible Reinhardt was. Perhaps de Kooning and Rothko* need to be depicted as the petit bourgeois accessories to civilisation crime they were. Fifty-fifty if Reinhardt's irascibility can be justified past his own dominion for artists that "those in possession of the truth take an obligation to throw the first stone," his obsession with repeating himself - often give-and-take for word - cannot be.

Reinhardt takes visible comfort in calling out others on their personal failures. Primary in his grievances is the allegedly phony intermingling of media. "Art is art. Everything else is everything else." Well, if Reinhardt is a student of rhetoric, isn't he fouling upwards the purity of his solar day job by importing rhetoric into art criticism? Isn't talking about art critically defiling art past associating it with words? Art is art. Words are words. Right?

I would capeesh Reinhardt more if - rather than publishing snide letters to the editors of civilisation pages and art magazines - he wrote a private memoir to exist published posthumously, giving his feelings at the time but in a less public, petulant, pathetic way.

There are other contradictions, but I give Reinhardt credit for never letting his ego or moral compass pull a fast one on him into believing he was anything other than human. Still, one cannot inactivate the ascertainment of these contradictions and not be irritated by them.

My word of advice for anyone interested in Ad Reinhardt: Notice the cartoons he did for the socialist newspapers and read his essays on Islamic, Chinese, and Khmer art. You do not demand this much view into Reinhardt'due south heed. You might not like what you encounter and it might affect the manner you look at his painting afterward.

*Though I nevertheless count Rothko as one of the iii greatest painters (call me a sentimentalist).

...more

January 17, 2014 Tosh rated it liked it

For me Advert Reinhardt is more than interesting every bit an artist than theorist. His cartoons and black paintings pretty much explains his aesthetic in themselves. Still his cranky commentary is very amusing. His stance against art is life is fascinating - and conspicuously how anyone can divide one's life from their art... Is that possible? For me Ad Reinhardt is more interesting as an artist than theorist. His cartoons and blackness paintings pretty much explains his aesthetic in themselves. Nevertheless his cranky commentary is very amusing. His stance against art is life is fascinating - and conspicuously how anyone tin separate one's life from their art... Is that possible? ...more than

Jan 12, 2010 Fifty rated it really liked it

Im a ridiculously big fan.

Apr 01, 2021 Tom rated information technology it was ok

Almost impossible to sympathize. Reinhardt (who'due south paintings intrigue me) rejects surrealism, but his writing comes off similar surrealist poetry. They are mostly a listing of statements that at times to contradict each other. They exercise have a sort of hypnotic quality where every in one case in a while a deeper pregnant seems to appear. I agree with his premise that art should be art alone and not a commodity, message, statement...... He thought he was painting the last paintings, and there'south something to that. Almost impossible to empathize. Reinhardt (who's paintings intrigue me) rejects surrealism, but his writing comes off similar surrealist poetry. They are mostly a list of statements that at times to contradict each other. They do have a sort of hypnotic quality where every once in a while a deeper meaning seems to announced. I concur with his premise that art should be art alone and not a commodity, message, statement...... He idea he was painting the final paintings, and in that location'southward something to that. Paintings I come across these days are representational or a riff on abstruse expressionism. He is an original. ...more

Feb 16, 2008 Andrew rated it it was astonishing

My friend Raha turned me onto Reinhardt many years ago, and this book in particular. Some other one I'd like to re-read. There is a book of Reinhardt'south satirical cartoons that is vivid which I picked up in Federal republic of germany two years ago. Has an English translation for the scholarly text role and all the cartoons are still in English language; it also includes some of his paintings. I like that volume almost equally much as this one. My friend Raha turned me onto Reinhardt many years ago, and this book in detail. Another one I'd like to re-read. There is a volume of Reinhardt's satirical cartoons that is bright which I picked up in Germany two years ago. Has an English language translation for the scholarly text function and all the cartoons are nonetheless in English; information technology also includes some of his paintings. I like that book almost as much as this i. ...more

Jan 09, 2015 Lechiot Volant rated it actually liked it

Ce livre est un livre engagé. Advertizement Reinhardt défend une théorie de la peinture épurée de tout ce qu'elle n'est pas. Il propose un travail aride, critique, quasi invisible comme une lutte contre la récupération, l'instrumentalisation, la marchandisation de l'fine art. Le ton, souvent caustique, parfois sévère, n'empêche pas l'ironie et la mégalomanie affichée cache une défense farouche d'une conception de l'fine art not assujettie à toute externalité. Ce livre est united nations livre engagé. Ad Reinhardt défend une théorie de la peinture épurée de tout ce qu'elle north'est pas. Il propose un travail aride, critique, quasi invisible comme une lutte contre la récupération, l'instrumentalisation, la marchandisation de fifty'art. Le ton, souvent caustique, parfois sévère, n'empêche pas l'ironie et la mégalomanie affichée cache une défense farouche d'une conception de l'fine art non assujettie à toute externalité. ...more

Oct 28, 2018 Lisa rated information technology liked information technology

A great introduction to the written material past Ad Reinhardt, the introductions Rose provides are also quite valuable.
Continue in mind, though, while reading that some of the articles have been edited to 'fit' into this book, significant that some of import parts of his writing take been edited out. A great introduction to the written cloth by Advertizing Reinhardt, the introductions Rose provides are also quite valuable.
Go on in mind, though, while reading that some of the articles accept been edited to 'fit' into this book, meaning that some important parts of his writing take been edited out. ...more